Not just a term: anti-mafia is a legislation

la legislazione anti-mafia

Anti-mafia is a word that encompasses a complex system of laws. Mafias are not fought with opinions but with the culture of law. It is a continuous, ten-year development that faces constant updates because mafias and the problems they pose are not static and crystallised in time but change with great complexity and speed. La legislazione antimafia (The anti-mafia legislation) is a volume of over 1,200 pages edited by Professors Enrico Mezzetti and Luca Lupária Donati (Zanichelli), together with over thirty contributors, which deals with all the legislation, commenting on it and explaining it. Mezzetti is Professor of Criminal Law and Commercial Criminal Law in the Department of Jurisprudence of the University of Roma Tre, and Professor of Anti-mafia Law and Legislation at the Carabinieri Officer School of Rome. With Professor Mezzetti, we deal not only with the fight against organised crime but with the very meaning of anti-mafia legislation.

I ask you a direct and no-nonsense question, apparently simple, but which hides a multiplicity of possible answers: what does mafia mean?

First of all, perhaps it would be more appropriate to speak of ‘mafias’, in the plural, given that the present conformation and finality of the ‘Ndrangheta, for example, with its system of ‘local’ formations and its capacity of propagation on the territory, does not resemble, at all, the other mafia structures, like the traditional and historical Sicilian one. Furthermore, it is necessary to take into account also the foreign mafias that operate in Italy, such as the Chinese, Russian and Nigerian mafia, which has induced the Legislator to modify the heading of the Art. 416 bis Criminal Code with the Law N° 125 of 2008, inserting in the heading of the Art. 416 bis, the express reference to the “Mafia-type associations, also involving foreigners”.

Mafia, or mafia-type phenomenon, means associated criminal associations organised in a hierarchical and quasi-military manner, dedicated to carrying out a criminal programme of offences resulting from the organisation’s illegal activity. From being a criminal organisation subversive of the democratic order and of the constitutional structures of the State, it has gradually transformed itself into a criminal phenomenon of ‘criminal enterprise’ which – by infiltrating the State’s organs and society and camouflaging itself in its folds – tends to carry out operations of distortion of the economic and financial activities, also through the control of public contracts and public works, effectively altering the regime of competition. Finally, another recently emerged aspect concerns the mafia political electoral exchange, aimed at conditioning electoral consultations to acquire illicit economic or institutional advantages.

Why is Italy the only country to have the word Mafia in its legal system? Is this a stigma or an advantage in being able to fight this particular criminal phenomenon? But, above all, by introducing the word mafia in the Criminal Code, what benefits would a foreign country have?

Italy is the only country to have the word mafia in its juridical system because this term has assumed a clear technical-juridical significance which has required the introduction of ad hoc legislation, which is lacking in other countries. Over time, the word has also acquired derogatory connotations about actions and criminal protagonists among the most dangerous in the society, coming to constitute, albeit negatively, in the collective imagination, also at an international level, a typical characteristic of our Country. The advantages consist in the rigorous provision of criminal offences that must be enforced according to the principle of strict legality, with the legislation specially envisaged for this particular criminal phenomenon entailing very severe measures of restriction of personal liberty, including preventive measures. The other countries should also adapt their legislation – as the phenomenon is now cross-border and, therefore, to be fought in a broader territory than the domestic one – to apply criminal jurisdiction homogeneously in an international perspective. The lack of express provision of the crime of mafia association, lacking the bilateral prevision of the fact, risks complicating the recourse to extradition and the use of instruments such as the European Arrest Warrant or the International Capture Warrant.

Mafias are fast. They circumvent laws, knowing how to interpret them and camouflaging themselves within the same folds. Is our anti-mafia legislation sufficient and fast enough to counteract the phenomenon?

Probably yes, although it is always improvable. The defect, which becomes a barrier, is at the international level, where a special legislation is lacking. And episodes like the massacre of Duisburg in Germany, or the spreading infiltrative presence of the ‘Ndrangheta in the City of London, demonstrate the obsolescence of the present measures of contrast in the international judicial cooperation.

The work of commentary and explanation of anti-mafia legislation directed by your colleague, Luca Lupària Donati, is monumental. How much is pure academic interest in tackling such a demanding task, and how much civil passion? How can we bring the two worlds into dialogue so that civil passion is not just an opinion but becomes an avenue for studies and vice versa?

I would say both. The editorial attempt that we have made with Mr Lupària and the entire vast group of co-authors – university professors, lawyers, magistrates, and civil servants – was precisely that of trying to open a fruitful dialogue between the various sectors of the society, as legal operators, so that they could ‘talk’ to each other to identify common plans of reflection and possible instruments of counteraction to the mafia phenomenon, from the juridical point of view, as well as political-institutional and economic-financial.

Thanks to Professor Daniele Piva, the Department of Law of the Roma Tre University has signed a memorandum of understanding with the Anti-Mafia Commission. What does a protocol of this magnitude propose, and what are the possible objectives?

To carry out in-depth research, aimed at scientifically studying the genesis of the criminal phenomenon – to identify the causes – which indeed depend also on deficits in the social structures – to research the lines of development – to identify possible remedies in the socio-political, rather than legal, sphere – to carry out statistical-criminological research to corroborate the conclusions and make them available to the bicameral Antimafia Commission as a representative of the Institutions and civil society; these are some of the critical aims. Furthermore, the University of Roma Tre is one of the few to have activated, for some years now, the specialistic course in Anti-mafia Law and Legislation, to sensitise also the young people on the central issues that our Country is facing.

A provocative question: we have all the laws at our disposal, the best legal minds at work, inside and outside the courtrooms, and yet the mafias seem to be an unbeatable enemy or at least one that resists the blows that are continually inflicted; why can’t we win once and for all?

The ability of mafias to camouflage themselves, their growth at a professional level, the speed with which they carry out their operations, making the most of the opportunities that the welfare state provides – such as subsidies, economic aid or incentives – together with the complacency, if not the cooperation or, sometimes the complicity of civil society, make the fight difficult, but many steps forward have been taken, and we are currently heading in the right direction.

Read the original article 

Leggi anche

 

Ultime notizie
pace
Attualità

Tempo di uccidere

Nella nostra cara, felice e ricca Europa, nessuno ci credeva. Ma, insomma, si chiedeva la gran massa delle persone, questi si vogliono davvero...
di Luciano Maria Teodori
pace
Laboratorio Europa
Intervista

Laboratorio Europa, alimentare il confronto su Istituzioni europee e sulla necessità di un’Europa sociale. Intervista al Prof. Umberto Triulzi

Laboratorio Europa dell’Eurispes, gli esperti si riuniscono per il primo incontro del 2023, attualmente coordinato dal Prof. Umberto Triulzi, economista, e docente di Politica economica europea, intervistato rispetto ai temi di discussione: Istituzioni europee, integrazione in ambito internazionale, Europa sociale.
di Silvia Muscas
Laboratorio Europa
complottismo
Attualità

Il dubbio e il burattinaio. Complottismo all’italiana

Cronaca e intrigo: anche per l’arresto di Matteo Messina Denaro, non sono mancati sospetti, dubbi, perplessità oltre l’accertamento dei fatti, con il risultato di offuscare il senso di una vittoria importante dello Stato contro la mafia. Il dovere di dubitare è una pratica essenziale nella società democratica, tuttavia bisogna contrastare il rischio dello scetticismo aprioristico e distruttivo.
di Angelo Perrone*
complottismo
editoria
Cultura

Editoria italiana: ricavi, geografia e nuove prospettive

L’editoria italiana ha registrato un calo del 2,8% nel 2022, ma i dati restano favorevoli rispetto al 2019. Crescono lettori e case editrici al Sud, pur restando al di sotto della media nazionale: lettori e case editrici si concentrano al Nord e al Centro, in Lazio e Lombardia ha sede il 38% delle case editrici italiane.
di Roberta Rega
editoria
bilancio energetico
Italia

Bilancio Energetico Nazionale, differenze regionali e potenzialità inespresse

Bilancio energetico nazionale, l’Italia ha un grande potenziale confermato da una quota del 20% di energie rinnovabili sul totale registrato nel 2020. A frenare la transizione ecologica però ci sono burocrazia e regionalismi che rischiano di allungare i tempi di decarbonizzazione dell’economia.
di Ludovico Semerari
bilancio energetico
prezzi della benzina
Fisco

Possibili profili speculativi sull’aumento dei prezzi della benzina e la marginalità delle cause fiscali

L’aumento del prezzo della benzina, di cui si parla molto ultimamente, è determinato da una serie di fattori che non limitano il dibattito alle semplici accise. A incidere è soprattutto la quotazione Platts, che viene decisa dalle compagnie in base al valore effettivo dei prodotti raffinati in un determinato momento.
di Giovambattista Palumbo*
prezzi della benzina
città
Futuro

La città nell’orizzonte della rivoluzione digitale

Le città raccontano chi siamo e che futuro vogliamo costruire: la rigenerazione urbana può essere la chiave per riconquistare gli spazi sottratti dalla pandemia, e costruire un universale urbano aperto al libero attraversamento di popoli ed etnie per una società sempre più fatta di migrazioni.
di Massimiliano Cannata
città
RAEE
Tecnologia

RAEE, rifiuti elettronici: un tesoro nascosto

I RAEE, i Rifiuti di apparecchiature elettriche ed elettroniche, vanno trattati in maniera del tutto speciale e secondo determinate modalità presso le isole ecologiche. Otto italiani su dieci dichiarano di possederne almeno uno, ma dal loro corretto smaltimenti si trarrebbe un significativo beneficio economico.
di Ilaria Tirelli
RAEE
imprese e sviluppo sostenibile
Futuro

Imprese e Sviluppo sostenibile, sempre più complesso il quadro delle nuove regole europee

Il 28 novembre 2022 il Consiglio Europeo ha approvato in via definitiva il testo della nuova direttiva sulla comunicazione delle imprese in...
di Fabrizio Zucca*
imprese e sviluppo sostenibile
Comunità Energetiche Rinnovabili
Italia Domani

Comunità energetiche rinnovabili: dal Pnrr nuovi modelli di crescita

Il doppio filo che lega Agenda 2030 e il PNRR si sta ulteriormente rafforzando attraverso la messa a punto di strumenti che...
di Claudia Bugno*
Comunità Energetiche Rinnovabili