Precarization, Lennart Nörreklit: from the dialogue of life to the fiction of social theatre


Precarization as a social phenomenon

The pandemic crisis has drastically highlighted a phenomenon that has been ignored for too long: precarization. There are many analyses of this concept from an economic point of view, but what does this phenomenon tell us when it is analyzed as a social concept, as a loss of community value? What importance does this value have, and what does its loss imply in terms of precariousness? These are the questions on which Lennart Nörreklit, professor emeritus at Aalborg University (DK), focuses in his Report 2022 of the European Network on Precarity SUPI.

Life as dialogue

«Life is a process of interaction of beings with their environment» explains Nörreklit. «If life thrives, the interaction is revealed as a form of intelligent interaction in which one assimilates and reflects the other. This is an intelligent process. It is a dialogue». Indeed, life takes place in relationships, and the elementary basis is dialogue, the interaction between two living beings. The importance of dialogue lies in the fusion of horizons, in the transmission of values; it is the engine by which character and knowledge are developed. Paradoxically, there is dialogue, the inner and personal one, even when we are alone.

The uniqueness of intrinsic values

We tend to think that everything can be replaced without considering that the only exception to this rule is the values. Intrinsic values, in fact, those that are not instrumental to something else, are based on their uniqueness, on their impossibility of being replaced. If we human beings are “guardians” of our values, their loss causes us pain; the threat of this loss has led us to develop social organization and technological tools, which are instrumental but necessary to preserve the intrinsic ones.

The eroded community: social theatre

According to Nörreklit’s analysis: «dialogue establishes common understanding, an understanding of why people feel and act a certain way. It is because of their values, situations, and possibilities to enforce values that people act in a certain way instead of another». Therefore, a community, seen as the basic social unit, is made up of people who preserve intrinsic values and create relationships through dialogue, becoming custodians of what become community values. «A theatre is different» Nörreklit goes on to specify, «in it, the actors are not concerned with being custodians of core values, but with positioning themselves in relation to others». This creates a social theatre, an environment where the actor-leader wants to prevail over the others, where power rules with lies, controlling the media, research, justice. The sense of community disappears, social cohesion and understanding are lost, there is no more empathy or mutual support. In the theatre scenario, therefore, the phenomenon of precariousness comes in a scenario that is studded with social threats and whose functioning is only and always in the hands of the leaders, who overlook and forget the people in precariousness.

Leggi anche

The pillars of modern society and precarization

Science and the capitalist economy are the two great pillars of modern society, two powers that operate through principles of abstraction and generalization, i.e., through an alternative power to the importance of dialogue and relational ties. If instrumental power predominates, as it does in social theatre, intrinsic values are compromised and life becomes precarious as a result. Abstraction and generalization are the basis of scientific theories. Through this language, the world is reduced to a physical structure with no reference to value, where the search for universal laws prevails rather than the construction of dialogue and interaction that binds people together. On the other hand, the capitalist monetary economy is based on a principle of substitutability. This makes the economy of scale possible, where the world is used as a resource to be exploited, and people are seen as a replaceable labor force. Personal relationships and the value of dialogue are seen as wastes of time, obstacles to the free exploitation of people. This leads to a disintegration of the community, to a loss of values, of family ties, of relationships, to an increase in the phenomenon of social precariousness. Then there is a third pillar that is slowly emerging today: technological development and Artificial Intelligence, an innovation that brings great economic and social change but which, as a means of control, will make it almost impossible to distinguish between reality and fiction.

Existential precarization

«The lockdown represents the closure of ’live communities’» Nörreklit continues, «as a result, we see the replacement of “live communities” by “web communities”. During the worldwide lockdown, everyone lives in a “Chinese room”, i.e., a place where communication takes place only in a hidden environment, without any semantics or practical action; therefore, there is no distinction between fiction and reality». For many professional groups, the lockdown has represented a departure from the community and a way to escape the stress caused by poor working conditions. The alienation from reality created by the lockdown thus produced an existential precarization, in which everyone’s life was locked into a symbolic world, depriving people of real communication. Video-conferencing and online contacts have led to creating a “network community” which, however, has the traits of fiction and social theatre: one does not really come into contact with the person, but only with their image. «Precariousness is the process that people experience when they discover that their life is slipping unstoppably into a fiction» adds Nörreklit. During the lockdown, each person remained locked in their personal Chinese room, experiencing only a simulacrum of community, a fiction where values do not matter.

The task of science: to serve dialogue

The loss of the community and its transformation into a social theatre have created the phenomenon of existential precariousness. The trauma caused by the pandemic and the lockdown will be challenging to overcome, and perhaps in some ways, the will is lacking. While the power to help, care and support each other is recognized in the community, in today’s society, this power is denied, transformed into something impersonal and subordinate to self-interest. It is necessary to rethink the role of science, which today is projected to promote human evolution through mechanisms that, paradoxically, lead to a further precariousness of life. The task of science should instead encompass the dialogue of life, its blessings, its vulnerability, its very possibility, including that of cultivating and enriching it. «Epistemology needs to analyze for the possibility to understand and support the deep individual relational bonding and intrinsic value formation», Lennart Nörreklit concludes, «the epistemological scientific focus on necessities should be subordinate to an epistemological scientific focus on analysing the individual possibilities for relation formation to enable intrinsic values». Ethics, dignity, and life are values that are defined through dialogue, the only means capable of building community and deconstructing the fictions of social theatre.

Read the original article

*Ida Nicotera, Eurispes International Dept.
**Lennart NörreklitSociologist, Professor emeritus, Aalborg University Aalborg – Denmark.
Reference: SUPI European Network on Social Precarity 2022 (Berlin-Rome).

Ultime notizie
Osservatorio Giochi

Osservatorio Giochi: il distanziometro e la “marginalizzazione” del gioco pubblico voluta dalle Regioni

Osservatorio Giochi, le politiche regionali più che espulso, hanno “marginalizzato” il gioco per contrastarne i conclamati effetti negativi. L’industria del gioco legale è inoltre sottoposta a rigide regolamentazioni e stringenti controlli, eppure è un settore che patisce cattiva informazione.
di Chiara Sambaldi e Andrea Strata*
Osservatorio Giochi
principio di rotazione
Criminalità e contrasto

Appalti, il principio di rotazione fra teoria e pratica

Il principio di rotazione garantisce trasparenza e imparzialità negli appalti pubblici, e impatta sulle procedure di oltre il 70% del totale degli affidamenti. Ma ne andrebbe differenziata l’applicazione in ragione della tipologia di affidamento.
di Simone Cannaroli
principio di rotazione

Le domande inevase sul Covid

Dopo la pandemia è rimasto un obbligo di chiarezza verso i singoli e la collettività, per dare conto di quanto ha funzionato e di ciò che è gravemente mancato. Le aspettative di verità e i desideri di giustizia sono troppo ampie per confidare soltanto sul processo penale: gestione delle emergenze, funzionamento della sanità pubblica, capacità di coordinamento dello Stato.
di Angelo Perrone

Insularità e autonomia differenziata. A che punto siamo? Intervista al Prof. Aldo Berlinguer

La nostra Costituzione riconosce il principio dell’insularità grazie alle modifiche intervenute nell’art. 119. D’altronde, l’applicazione di tale principio porta con sé ancora...
di Susanna Fara
Osservatorio sulla PA

Appalti: il principio del risultato, la novità

Il nuovo Codice Appalti 2023 si apre con l’enunciazione dei princìpi ispiratori e con quella che potrebbe rappresentare la novità più rilevante del nuovo impianto normativo: il principio del risultato.
di Simone Cannaroli
armi da fuoco

Armi da fuoco, un pericolo prima che una difesa per la maggioranza degli italiani

Armi da fuoco, un italiano su quattro le comprerebbe per sé, ma il 44,8% del campione le considera un pericolo più che una opportunità. A giudizio di circa un italiano su tre non dovrebbero incriminare chi reagisce a una rapina. Cresce la paura di essere vittima di omicidio.
di redazione
armi da fuoco

Cittadini e sicurezza: tra realtà e percezione. Emergono sfiducia nei mass-media e timore dei reati informatici

Sicurezza e cittadini, qual è il rapporto tra realtà e percezione? Il furto in casa è il reato più temuto da sempre, ma cresce la preoccupazione per il furto di dati su Internet, fenomeno incrementato dagli acquisti online in pandemia. Media poco attendibili, solo il 27,9% del campione li giudica realistici.
di Angelo Caliendo
Sondaggi & Ricerche

Delittuosità in Italia: meno omicidi ma cresce la criminalità minorile

Criminalità in Italia, l’indagine Eurispes evidenzia un dimezzamento degli omicidi dal 2007 a oggi, ma preoccupa la criminalità minorile, in crescita del +13,8% dal 2019.
di redazione

Metaverso, che cosa ne pensano gli italiani

Fra criticità e opportunità, il mondo del Metaverso sta andando rapidamente avanti e sembra essere ormai una realtà con cui l’umanità sarà destinata a convivere. Ma quanto ne sanno gli italiani di questo mondo che si muove all’interno delle nuove tecnologie della comunicazione? Che cosa ne pensano e quali sensazioni evoca in loro? L’Eurispes ha cercato di dare risposta a queste domande sondando l'opinione dei cittadini.
di redazione

La valorizzazione dell’autoconsumo: nuovi perimetri per l’energia elettrica condivisa e autoconsumata

Autoconsumo, si va verso la definizione dei soggetti interessati e dei perimetri geografici che agevolano le comunità energetiche. Il Testo Integrato sull’Autoconsumo Diffuso adottato da Arera ha lo scopo di semplificare e razionalizzare le regole per l’accesso al servizio di autoconsumo.
di Avv. Daniela Pappadà